‘Ross McMullin argues rightly that an Australian who achieved so much “deserves to be better remembered”. His vivid, thorough biography is the first full account of Elliott’s life — surprising, given Pompey’s eminence, popularity and personality … Elliott's story — the great-hearted captain broken by life’s blows — is a tragedy of Shakespearean dimensions, and our history is the richer for McMullin's telling of it.’
Peter Fuller, Australian Book Review
‘[Pompey Elliott] may be the best Australian military biography yet to appear'.
Stephen Loosley, Sunday Telegraph
’He is tough and tender, cocksure and vulnerable, charismatic and cranky, a burly and ruddy-cheeked man who, once seen, is not to be forgotten … Here is a fine piece of storytelling, a journey back to an Australia that is long gone. Here is a narrative that never stalls but carries us along like a river heading for the sea. Here is Pompey Elliott, bursting out of the page, larger than life and worn down by life.’
Les Carlyon, foreword to the 2008 edition
‘Being a child of parents and grandparents deeply affected by the holocaust and World War II, I have only ever immersed myself in that literature. I’ve been an anti-war campaigner, an active ignorer of Anzac Day, a cynic about jingoism, and an ignoramus about Australian history. However, Ross McMullin’s biography converted me into someone totally gripped by a military tale full of intrigue, politics, love, comradeship, and what it is to be a man, a soldier and an Australian.’
Adjunct Professor Amaryll Perlesz
‘This life of achievement, colour, celebrity and tragedy has been wonderfully re-created by McMullin, whose insight also sets the life into a wider history of its times.’
Peter Ryan, Quadrant
‘For readers interested in military history, and more broadly the society that shaped the first AIF, the book is close to a masterpiece of traditional biography, specific in scope and monumental in structure … McMullin’s book provides a great deal — at 700-odd pages, a great, great deal — to delight in.’
Stephen Matchett, Sydney Institute Quarterly
‘A striking aspect of Ross McMullin’s scrupulous biography is how little Elliott has been exaggerated by posterity … Pompey Elliott is a large book, and rightly. It encompasses a period and individuals of more than mere military significance. It is difficult to dissent from McMullin’s judgment that Fromelles — an engagement not one in a thousand Australians would know of today, because it hasn’t occasioned a movie or mini-series — remains “perhaps the most tragic 24 hours ever experienced by Australians”, its losses being equivalent to the entire Australian casualties of the Boer War, the Korean War and the Vietnam War put together.
‘The assiduous McMullin has scored several scoops, including the revelation that Elliott argues successfully against an appallingly misconceived advance on St Denis Wood shortly after the battle of Mont St Quentin in September 1918 — in the lives preserved, an achievement as considerable as any great battlefield coup.’
Gideon Haigh, The Age
‘In the ultimate sentence of the book McMullin says: “an Australian as famous, inspirational, and historically significant as ‘Pompey’ Elliott deserves to better remembered”. With this book, the first fully researched account of Elliott's life and times, McMullin makes a significant contribution to ensuring that this happens.’
Geoff Pryor, Canberra Times
‘Australians who don’t read this book are short-changing themselves’
Peter Ryan, The Australian
‘Ross McMullin’s biography is an engrossing and capable study of this outstanding figure, who was undoubtedly one of the great Australian characters of the First World War … McMullin is to warmly commended for a major contribution to the body of work documenting this country's military past.’
Chris Coulthard-Clark, Wartime
‘One of the best three or four books ever written by an Australian on the Great War.’
Les Carlyon